Home » defamation lawyer » Defamation lawyer on defamatory search results on Google

Defamation lawyer on defamatory search results on Google

Follow me on Twitter

Advertisements

Defamation lawyer asks: Do you think that Google should be responsible for defamatory results that appear on its search results? If the person who posted defamatory allegations about you on the internet cannot be traced, is it fair to allow Google to carry on pointing internet users to the defamatory web page through its search engine?

Google’s view on this is that they are not responsible for internet content, even on their own free Blogger sites and that they are also not responsible for what content appears on the search results.

Google has been claiming in various courts (of democratic countries)  that it has no control over search results but this assertion is difficult to reconcile with its ability and willingness to omit and manipulate search results in countries such as China and Saudi Arabia.

In an interesting twist in a Court of Appeal case which concerns the former conservative council candidate Payam Tamiz, his Barrister Goldwin Busutill made this interesting observation to the court:

‘The notion that the internet runs “automatically” or “passively” is in essence a powerful myth which has been fostered very successfully and profitably by internet superpowers such as Google Inc. It suits their business model to take and to be seen to be taking a ‘‘hands off’’ approach and not really able to do anything about problems that may be generated by their internet-based operations.’

The idea that companies can rip enormous financial benefits without having to incur any risks or liabilities to the citizens of this country is foreign to the English tradition of ‘fair play’.

The same issue has recently been highlighted in the media in relation to the low level of taxes which is paid in the UK by some multinational companies (such as Google and Amazon).

There is a perception that there is something very secretive about these sorts of companies whose operation appears to be anything but transparent.

This apparent lack of transparency might provide these companies with tremendous short term gains but eventually it will come back to bite them.

Written by Defamation lawyer Yair Cohen

 Defamation lawyers website.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Posts by date

RSS Internet Law Experts

  • Contact Us 13/06/2019
    (function(d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = "//forms.aweber.com/form/66/5279566.js"; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); }(document, "script", "aweber-wjs-sahq1fizo"));
  • Facebook's Removal of Right Wing Extremists is a Bad Idea 08/05/2019
    Facebook has thrown the book at several prominent people. It calls them “dangerous individuals” and they include people accused of hate speech anti-Semitism and white supremacist views. Recently, on LBC, Yair Cohen was asked by Eddie Mair: 'What do you what do you think of Facebook's action here?' I think it is very difficult to justify this a […]
  • Data Protection Breach or Political Motivation? 07/05/2019
    Did Huawei have 'Hidden Back Doors' or is it just coincidental that breach information was delivered by 'Anonymous Sources' to an American Media Company? Apparently, some people that don't want to be identified, contacted Bloomberg to tell them that Vodafone discovered 'hidden back doors' in their routers that were made by […]
  • Harassment Lawyer Yair Cohen Helped Lindsey Goldrick Dean Win Freedom After 13 Years of Harassment 12/07/2018
    Lindsey Goldrick with her lawyer Yair Cohen London, UK Harassment lawyer won case for his client after 13 years of police inaction Harassment lawyer Yair Cohen took over the case from police after police gave up on pressing charges against the most notorious online harasser in the UK. Paul Currant harassed his victim for nearly 13 years but eventually was tr […]
  • Administrators of Facebook fan pages are liable under GDPR 12/06/2018
    Is a Facebook fan page administrator liable under GDPR? according to the European Court, an administrator of a fan page on Facebook is jointly responsible, together with Facebook for processing data of visitors to the Facebook fan page. But what are the implications for administrators of other social media pages such as LinkedIn for example? Yair Cohen socia […]
  • Social media content moderation and removal policies: Some rare insights – Yair Cohen 19/02/2018
    via Social media content moderation and removal policies: Some rare insights – Yair Cohen
  • Right to be forgotten 21/11/2017
    How to make a successful right to be forgotten application On 12 October 2014, Google reported to have rejected more than two thirds of all the ‘right to be forgotten’ applications they received from UK applicants. Google’s decision to comply with any such applications is of course at their discretion (albeit in accordance with the landmark court ruling made […]
  • Remove search results from Google worldwide 30/06/2017
    So where do Europeans stand in relation to the removal of Google search results worldwide? July 2017 update. From the day Google was told to remove search results worldwide, Europeans residents are eagerly awaiting the French High Court’s decision on an appeal by Google. In May 2015 French data regulator ordered Google to apply a Right to be Forgotten remova […]
%d bloggers like this: